A Lyon County district judge dismissed three of four claims brought by former Fernley City Councilman Stan Lau against the City of Fernley, while allowing a narrowed free-speech retaliation claim to move forward and giving Lau 30 days to seek permission to amend his complaint.
In an order filed Nov. 5, Third Judicial District Court Judge Leon Aberasturi granted the city’s motion to dismiss Lau’s due process, equal protection and civil conspiracy claims. The judge ruled that those claims either could not be brought under the Nevada Constitution as pleaded or failed to state sufficient facts.
The lawsuit stems from the Fernley City Council’s 3-2 vote to expel Lau from office on March 4. Lau alleged the action was retaliation for protected speech and for complaints he made concerning fellow council member Albert Torres.
Lau filed the original complaint against the city and Torres on March 16 and an amended complaint on March 19. Also on March 19, Torres filed a motion to dismiss, and on May 23, a new filing by Lau dismissed Torres from the lawsuit.
City Attorney Aaron Mouritsen said government officials generally are difficult to sue individually for actions taken as part of their official duties.
“And piercing that veil to go for people individually is always very difficult because you either have to show that they acted in such a way that it was unreasonable to even think that was part of their job, or, if they weren't doing it in their official capacity,” Mouritsen said.
The city filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit on July 7, and Lau filed an opposition to that motion on July 22. The court held a hearing on the matter Sept. 22, and the judge said he also reviewed supplemental briefings submitted between Oct. 7 and Oct. 29.
In the order filed Nov. 5, Aberasturi dismissed Lau’s due process, equal protection and civil conspiracy claims and found that the complaint lacked sufficient allegations that all three council members who voted to expel Lau acted with a retaliatory motive.
The judge ruled Lau may file a request to amend his complaint within 30 days to address the finding that the complaint did not sufficiently allege retaliatory motives by council members Torres, Joe Mendoza and Felicity Zoberski, who voted to expel him.
“The judge gave him some leave to modify and amend his complaint to clarify the legal basis he had for the allegations against the city,” Mouritsen said. “The judge said, if you want to prove this claim, you have to prove two things. Number one, that each member of the voting majority acts with a retaliatory motive, and then two, the members agree to accomplish that unlawful objective.”
On Nov. 6, the day after the judge’s order was filed, Lau filed a request for leave to file a second amended complaint. The filing includes an exhibit with a copy of the proposed second amended complaint, which attempts to allege that Torres, Mendoza and Zoberski acted together in voting to table one of Lau’s agenda items and later expel him.
Mouritsen said the city disputes those allegations.
“That’s still our position, is that they didn’t act in some kind of way to go after him in an illegal way,” Mouritsen said. “They were expelling him for his actions, not for any retaliatory reason.”
Mouritsen said the city also questions how Lau intends to support his allegations against the other council members.
“I would like to understand why he thinks Felicity and Joe are acting in retaliation for something that he says he did to Albert Torres,” Mouritsen said.
The second amended complaint has not been filed, and a district court clerk said Nov. 17 there have been no additional filings in the case since Nov. 6.
Attorney Jeff Dickerson, representing Lau, did not respond to multiple requests for comment before deadline.

Comment
Comments