Before I wade into what I’m about to say, I want to make clear the limits of my own perspective. I’m not a global traveler and I don’t have a passport stamped with European capitals or Asian metros. I’ve never even spent more than two separate afternoons outside the border of the United States, and even on those occasions it was no farther away than a few miles from it in Juarez and Tijuana.
Because of that, I have no idea whether our fractured political culture is a uniquely U.S. phenomenon. I suspect the short answer is no, that it is a global epidemic, but I also suspect that how we experience that in the U.S. might be structurally distinct from places with vastly different forms of governance.
But I don’t need to have visited those places to believe that, whatever may be the same or different on the other side of an ocean or a river, what we are doing here is not working.
Decades ago, former Speaker of the House Tip O’Neill used the phrase “All politics is local” as the title of his book. I have no idea whether I would agree with any of his specific policy beliefs, but I agree with that phrase wholeheartedly.
After stepping down from the presidency in 1809, Thomas Jefferson wrote that “The care of human life and happiness, and not their destruction, is the first and only legitimate object of good government."
Jefferson had just finished serving eight grueling years as president during a time when the country was so divided there were fears of a civil war. You can read for yourself the clashing visions of the Federalists and their incumbent president John Adams, and the Democratic-Republican party led by his vice president, Jefferson. The details are far too complex to get into is this short space, but they serve to express my greater point.
Even after that race, Jefferson famously said, "I never considered a difference of opinion in politics, in religion, in philosophy, as cause for withdrawing from a friend."
Jefferson was a formidable political brawler, not some naïve simpleton or weakling, but he understood that we should separate a person’s political views from their human value.
If we combine that with the belief that all politics are local, then the most critical political space is not a voting booth, a city council chamber or a congressional hearing room. It’s conversation at the dinner table, in a grocery store aisle or over the backyard fence.
I happen to have two close friends who lean pretty far on opposite ends of the political spectrum, and I love listening to both of them. They both make me see things in a way I hadn’t considered. If I ever introduced them to each other, they would probably argue pretty heatedly and end up not liking each other at all, which is pretty sad to think about, because they’re both great people and otherwise have quite a bit in common.
I doubt that my two friends will ever vote the same way, and that’s perfectly fine with me. What I’d love is to sit down at the same table with both of them, watch them disagree completely, and still leave respecting each other. Being able to do that would be far more important than the outcome of any single election.

Comment
Comments