Go to main contentsGo to main menu
Wednesday, November 18, 2026 at 10:57 AM

Congress looks at wild horses (again), and there are no easy solutions

Congress looks at wild horses (again), and there are no easy solutions


By Daniel Rothberg

https://thenevadaindependent.com



Few public lands issues in the American West are as charged as the question of how to manage wild horses. And nowhere is the issue more challenging than in Nevada. More than half of the roughly 73,000 horses that roam federal land live here. They fill the state’s rangelands, the desolate basins that stretch across the Great Basin region.

Across the United States, they are seen as unique symbols of Western freedom, figures that evoke the unrestrained frontier. But wild horses and the ecosystems they inhabit face a less visible reality, one that most politicians acknowledge as a long-term threat to the range.

The wild horse population of about 73,000 far exceeds what the Bureau of Land Management believes to be sustainable, 27,000. On top of that number, more mustangs, about 44,000, have been captured during years of BLM roundups and live off the range in corrals or on pastures.

With a new administration in the White House, Congress is again debating what to do about wild horses, a protected species that has its own carve-out in federal law. The Wild Horses and Burros Act, passed in 1971, required the BLM to protect wild horses as a symbol of the West.

The problem has always been, according to the BLM, that it has few tools to do so. There are few predators in the areas with excess wild horses. Unlike other wildlife, the wild horse population cannot be controlled by hunting. Birth control is one favored approach but it can be expensive and some advocates oppose its use.

So for decades, the management for wild horses has been to collect them in roundups the BLM calls “gathers.” The horses, which Congress declared “living symbols of the historic and pioneer spirit of the West,” are then held in captivity by the BLM, where they often live out their lives. As of last year, about 12,500 horses were kept in holding corrals and another 31,000 in pastures. They await sale or adoption, though few are adopted, and sales are limited by stipulations that work to prevent sale for slaughter. In old age or sickness, they are allowed to be euthanized.

The result is that many “wild horses” are no longer in the wild, said David Philipps, a New York Times reporter whose new book “Wild Horse Country”  tracks the history of horses in the West.

“Our entire approach is a giant contradiction,” he said. “It’s not a surprise that no one is happy with it.”

In a budget proposal earlier this year, the BLM under the Trump administration called for the “humane euthanasia and unrestricted sale of certain excess animals.” The BLM’s push to cull horse herds would lift restrictions that prevent sales to slaughterhouses in Mexico and Canada.

The 1971 law technically would allow this, but neither the public nor Congress have supported those measures. When Congress approves the BLM budget it usually places restrictions on the killing of healthy horses through unrestricted sale or euthanasia. That could change this year, wild horse advocates worry.

In July,  a House Appropriations Committee approved an amendment from Utah Rep. Chris Stewart that lifted the prohibition on euthanizing healthy excess wild horses. Supporters of it emphasized that these horses could not be sold to slaughter for commercial products, but he faced pushback from advocates and several lawmakers, including Rep. Dina Titus.

Titus sponsored an opposing amendment to restrict killing healthy horses, but the proposal was rejected in the House Rules Committee and never received a vote, according to her office.

“I’m under no illusion that there are real challenges to the management of our wild horse and burro population,” Titus told a congressional committee, pushing to put the legislation to a vote. “But I believe that the changes that are being proposed…to lift the more than two-decades ban on federally-funded slaughter of these animals is not the answer to management.”

After the Stewart Amendment passed, wild horse advocates called it a “death warrant.“

The proposal now awaits consideration in the Senate, where even concerned wild horse advocates believe it is unlikely to pass. There’s one political consideration that has always saved wild horse populations: the public is overwhelmingly opposed to killing healthy horses.

The advocates are more concerned that language could be inserted by a conference committee, the panel of lawmakers that convene to iron out differences in House and Senate bills.

“That’s where the bigger threat is,” said Deniz Bolbol, a communications director for the American Wild Horse Preservation Campaign, which is active in Nevada and the West.

Even those who supported the Stewart Amendment see it as a last resort.

Rep. Mark Amodei, who represents Northern Nevada, supported the Stewart Amendment, which allows euthanasia of healthy horses. But he told the Elko County Commission in August that it was not a “panacea” and that it was important to build support around other options. “If we don’t get behind a birth control option as a tool,” he said, “the only stuff that’s left is euthanasia.”

During his presentation, Amodei told commissioners that he hoped the Stewart amendment would place pressure on politicians and advocates to support a fertility management program.

“I don’t think [public lands] can be continued to be expected to absorb more and more pressure from one species to the detriment of other species,” said Amodei, who sees it as a priority.

Ranchers, whose cattle compete with wild horses for forage and water, have sued the BLM, alleging that the agency should be allowed to sell wild horses without limitation. A Reno court dismissed the suit, from the Nevada Association of Counties and the Nevada Farm Bureau, in 2015 and the 9th Circuit denied an appeal earlier this year, according to the Associated Press.

“We support removing the riders that Congress has put on in the past and allowing unlimited sale,” Doug Busselman, the farm bureau’s vice president, said in an interview last week. “Trying to pretend that limited non-management is going to somehow solve the issue is a fallacy.”

He said the current situation is setting up a scenario in which horses, in overpopulated herd areas, become emaciated and starve to death or die of thirst in drought conditions. Overgrazing in areas with overpopulated wild horses, he said, damages the range for all species. State wildlife officials said overpopulation can interfere with other uses, like sage-grouse protection.

Wild horse advocates say these claims are overstated. The BLM’s policies sway in favor of ranchers, they argue, and overgrazing is the result of cattle, which far outnumber horses.

“It’s all skewed in livestock’s favor,” said Bobol, the communications director for the American Wild Horse Preservation Campaign. “And the wild horses are scapegoated for everything.”

Advocates and some wildlife managers believe the BLM is jumping to an extreme answer —  killing healthy wild horses — without exploring all approaches. But in recent years, as the captive horse population has increased, the BLM’s funding has shifted away from management. It’s just trying to keep up. More than half of federal horse management funding now goes to care for wild horses off-range, a program that the BLM foresees costing $1 billion over the horses’ lifetimes.

“They’ve essentially stopped doing anything,” Philipps said.

A plan to address the issue should combine several approaches but rely as much as possible on natural interactions with wildlife, he said. That would require the BLM and other federal agencies to coordinate wild horse management with its plans for mountain lions, a predator.

“I don’t think there is one solution,” he added. “There are probably many.”

A National Academy of Sciences report, compiled in 2013 by a panel of experts, listed the use of fertility control as a promising path. Continuing ‘business as usual,’ the report said, “will be expensive and unproductive for BLM and the public it serves.” But even birth control has its drawbacks. Fertility control can be expensive and a challenge to administer. Some treatments require a booster every year. Some wild horse advocates have even sued to stop birth control.

A few Western states have tried to pressure the BLM or take some control from the agency.

This year, Utah lawmakers proposed managing the population by handing more control to the state. Last year, Gov. Brian Sandoval threatened to sue the BLM if it did not adequately fund its wild horse management program. At the time, the governor’s office said in a news release that overpopulation threatened greater sage-grouse habitat and put stress on ranchers near Elko.

“The BLM has underfunded the wild horse program for years and as a result, the livelihood of our local economies is now being threatened. For too long, Nevada has been forced to compensate for the federal government’s inability to manage these growing populations without the appropriate resources,” Sandoval said.

Lynn Huntsinger, an ecology professor at Berkeley and an author of the National Academy of Sciences study, said the most socially acceptable solution probably lies in controlling fertility.

“You don’t have any good tools right now,” she said.



Share
Rate

Comment

Comments

COMMENTS
Comment author: John Mueller Comment text: FERNLEY’S WATER EMERGENCY: FIVE QUESTIONS STILL NEED ANSWERS The November 12 Fernley Reporter article provides a good recap of the November 3 water emergency and the November 4 City Council meeting. First, credit where credit is due. Our city employees responded, restored operations, and took precautions to protect residents. That’s important and appreciated. But fixing the immediate problem isn’t the same as preventing it from happening again. There are five reasonable questions our community deserves answers to: 1. WHAT ACTUALLY FAILED? What was the root cause of the water treatment plant’s communication failure, and why didn’t the backup systems prevent the interruption? 2. HOW CLOSE WERE WE TO A REAL EMERGENCY? How much usable water remained in storage, and how close did we come to affecting essential services, including firefighting? 3. WHAT WILL THIS COST TAXPAYERS AND RATEPAYERS? What did the emergency cost, what additional repairs or upgrades are necessary, and how will they be funded? 4. WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR MAKING SURE IT DOESN’T HAPPEN AGAIN? Is there a written corrective-action plan with assigned responsibilities, measurable results, and completion deadlines? 5. HOW WILL RESIDENTS KNOW THE PROBLEM IS REALLY FIXED? Will the city publish an after-action report explaining what happened, what was learned, what has been corrected, and what still needs attention? This isn’t about pointing fingers or finding someone to blame. It’s about learning, improving, and protecting our community. We can appreciate the city’s response while still expecting transparency, accountability, and a commitment to continuous improvement. Some technical information may need to remain confidential for security reasons. But that shouldn’t prevent residents from understanding the risks, the corrective actions, and the results. The real question isn’t whether Fernley recovered from the November 3 emergency. We know it did. The question is: If the same failure happened tomorrow, would we be better prepared? That’s a conversation worth having. Our community deserves more than reassurance. It deserves measurable results. Comment publication date: 11/12/26, 1:54 PM Comment source: Fernley Council Addresses Water Emergency Comment author: Donald DeVold Comment text: Great article It’s actually spelled DeVold Thank you Comment publication date: 10/29/26, 4:58 PM Comment source: The great robbery: Strip-6 by Solis helps Vaqueros punch playoff ticket Comment author: CH Comment text: I want to start a betting 'pool' for the October, November, and December closures: 1. A dent in the pool slide. 2. A failed breaker. 3. A pebble loose in the water part (replacing all concrete) 4. Hurricane Polo makes a sudden turn and blows off the roof (again). With soft muscles after 7 months of no swimming, the only health left is my sense of humor :) Comment publication date: 10/1/26, 11:18 AM Comment source: Fernley Pool Renovation Moves Forward, One Test at a Time Comment author: PFB Comment text: Why can't you guys find competent contractors.. For a large municipal facility like the indoor-outdoor Fernley Swimming Pool located at 300 Cottonwood Lane, a complete ground-up commercial build or major structural renovation typically spans 6 to 12 months or longer when factoring in large-scale engineering, public municipal permitting, specialized commercial HVAC/roofing, and health department inspections. The current renovation has been- The Fernley Swimming Pool has been closed for approximately six to seven months since late February 2026 for a major roof replacement and facility renovation. Now you sat October. Soooo 8 months for a new roof. The picture shows no other renovations. Comment publication date: 9/17/26, 7:14 PM Comment source: Electrical problem delays Fernley pool opening Comment author: P Comment text: Relative of the Mayor is to over see this site. Anyone who knows Fernley KNOWS this is more of the who you are related to and know business in this town. VOTE THEM ALL OUT AND THE CALIFORNIA TRANSPLANTS. Comment publication date: 9/16/26, 10:31 PM Comment source: Lift Station Failure Released Untreated Sewage Comment author: Christopher Walsh Comment text: Could you look into the strong recurring smell around Fernley? It smells like sewage and it can be bad enough that people don’t want to be outside or open their windows. It would be helpful to get an investigative journalist help the Fernley residents get a clear answer from the City, NDEP, and any involved facilities. I was really disappointed that the smell was not disclosed by my realtor when I moved here. I enjoy Fernley and am seeing the improvements that are being made. With Appreciation Comment publication date: 9/12/26, 2:49 PM Comment source: Sewage spill near City of Fernley Municipal Well 9