Go to main contentsGo to main menu
Wednesday, November 18, 2026 at 11:05 AM

ACLU files long-threatened lawsuit alleging Nevada's overstretched rural public defender system is unconstitutional

ACLU files long-threatened lawsuit alleging Nevada's overstretched rural public defender system is unconstitutional
Plants bloom in Red Rock Canyon National Conservation Area on Tuesday, May 9, 2017. Photo by Jeff Scheid.


By Michelle Rindels

https://thenevadaindependent.com

The American Civil Liberties Union of Nevada is suing the state and Gov. Brian Sandoval, alleging that the public defender system in sparsely populated rural counties is so threadbare that it’s unconstitutional.

The group filed a lawsuit Thursday in the 1st District Court in Carson City, arguing that the state’s failure to offer meaningful financial support to rural counties so they can pay for attorneys to represent the poorest clients means people are languishing in jail — losing jobs, relationships and property in the process — and getting shoddy representation by overworked and overwhelmed lawyers. Several reports over the years have highlighted the issue, but the state still hasn’t funded a permanent solution; the closest it came is a bill passed this legislative session that studies the issue.

“The State and the Governor have repeatedly failed to fix the system,” the suit says. “Meanwhile, people accused of crimes in Nevada’s rural counties who cannot afford a lawyer continue to be herded through the criminal justice system without the basic constitutional protection of meaningful representation.”

Sandoval’s office said they would review the filing.

“The filing of a lawsuit is disappointing, as the Office of the Governor had previously worked in collaboration with the Supreme Court, the Legislature and other advocacy groups on this issue,” said spokeswoman Mari St. Martin. “Governor Sandoval had taken significant steps to improve rural indigent defense including signing into law a measure which created a rural judicial district. This provides greater access to justice for many living in rural communities. He also signed a law this year which created an Indigent Defense Commission. The Commission will look at the caseload and workload of defense counsel, minimum standards for legal representation of indigent defendants, and how to fund a statewide indigent defense system.”

The Nevada Supreme Court has applied $230,000 to the commission, which is led by Chief Justice Michael Cherry.

“Everyone in our state deserves an attorney regardless of their ability to pay for that representation,” Cherry said in a statement after the bill was signed into law. “It is time we did this and I am pleased we’re moving forward.”

An earlier form of the bill was stronger, giving the commission the power to implement and enforce standards of indigent defense, rather than just recommend changes. Opponents of that version included the Humboldt County Public Defender, who testified that local control was better and a statewide public defender system used in past years offered rural counties incompetent, urban lawyers with high turnover.

Sandoval’s office also noted he signed SB29 in 2017, a bill that allows rural defendants to transfer to urban jurisdictions so they can enroll in specialty court programs, such as drug court or mental health court.

The suit paints a dire picture of the public defender system in rural Nevada, where the state prosecuted nearly 4,000 indigent defendants in fiscal years 2015 and 2016.

Small rural counties contract with attorneys for a flat annual fee ranging from $88,000 a year in Lyon County to $196,000 in Douglas County, but the fee often must cover investigative and expert witness costs for an unlimited number of defendants. Contracts often don’t include reimbursement for traveling the vast stretches of the state’s rural counties and can allow the attorneys to also pick up private clients on the side, diluting time spent on indigent clients.

The plaintiffs in the case describe attorneys who are nearly impossible to reach and don’t meet with them except in open court for just minutes at a time. The public defenders are swamped — one attorney in Nye County, for example, was assigned 253 misdemeanor cases, 41 gross misdemeanor cases and 159 felony cases in fiscal year 2016, but only requested funds nine times to hire an expert and seven times to hire an investigator, according to the lawsuit.

One plaintiff, Jason Lee Enox, has been in jail for 19 months and has had persistent troubles contacting his court-appointed lawyer or getting updates about his case. The ACLU said he eventually took a plea deal because he faced a “catastrophic verdict” in a trial for which his attorney had not interviewed witnesses or otherwise conducted an investigation; he now faces 11 to 27 years in prison.

The ACLU is seeking a court order that, among other things, would require the state to propose a plan for offering meaningful indigent defense and bar the flat fee contracts that the organization says provide no incentives for lawyers to spend significant time working on individual cases.

The Sixth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees the accused the right to the a speedy trial and the assistance of counsel.

This story was updated at 3:45 p.m. to include comment from Gov. Brian Sandoval’s office.

Share
Rate

Comment

Comments

COMMENTS
Comment author: John Mueller Comment text: FERNLEY’S WATER EMERGENCY: FIVE QUESTIONS STILL NEED ANSWERS The November 12 Fernley Reporter article provides a good recap of the November 3 water emergency and the November 4 City Council meeting. First, credit where credit is due. Our city employees responded, restored operations, and took precautions to protect residents. That’s important and appreciated. But fixing the immediate problem isn’t the same as preventing it from happening again. There are five reasonable questions our community deserves answers to: 1. WHAT ACTUALLY FAILED? What was the root cause of the water treatment plant’s communication failure, and why didn’t the backup systems prevent the interruption? 2. HOW CLOSE WERE WE TO A REAL EMERGENCY? How much usable water remained in storage, and how close did we come to affecting essential services, including firefighting? 3. WHAT WILL THIS COST TAXPAYERS AND RATEPAYERS? What did the emergency cost, what additional repairs or upgrades are necessary, and how will they be funded? 4. WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR MAKING SURE IT DOESN’T HAPPEN AGAIN? Is there a written corrective-action plan with assigned responsibilities, measurable results, and completion deadlines? 5. HOW WILL RESIDENTS KNOW THE PROBLEM IS REALLY FIXED? Will the city publish an after-action report explaining what happened, what was learned, what has been corrected, and what still needs attention? This isn’t about pointing fingers or finding someone to blame. It’s about learning, improving, and protecting our community. We can appreciate the city’s response while still expecting transparency, accountability, and a commitment to continuous improvement. Some technical information may need to remain confidential for security reasons. But that shouldn’t prevent residents from understanding the risks, the corrective actions, and the results. The real question isn’t whether Fernley recovered from the November 3 emergency. We know it did. The question is: If the same failure happened tomorrow, would we be better prepared? That’s a conversation worth having. Our community deserves more than reassurance. It deserves measurable results. Comment publication date: 11/12/26, 1:54 PM Comment source: Fernley Council Addresses Water Emergency Comment author: Donald DeVold Comment text: Great article It’s actually spelled DeVold Thank you Comment publication date: 10/29/26, 4:58 PM Comment source: The great robbery: Strip-6 by Solis helps Vaqueros punch playoff ticket Comment author: CH Comment text: I want to start a betting 'pool' for the October, November, and December closures: 1. A dent in the pool slide. 2. A failed breaker. 3. A pebble loose in the water part (replacing all concrete) 4. Hurricane Polo makes a sudden turn and blows off the roof (again). With soft muscles after 7 months of no swimming, the only health left is my sense of humor :) Comment publication date: 10/1/26, 11:18 AM Comment source: Fernley Pool Renovation Moves Forward, One Test at a Time Comment author: PFB Comment text: Why can't you guys find competent contractors.. For a large municipal facility like the indoor-outdoor Fernley Swimming Pool located at 300 Cottonwood Lane, a complete ground-up commercial build or major structural renovation typically spans 6 to 12 months or longer when factoring in large-scale engineering, public municipal permitting, specialized commercial HVAC/roofing, and health department inspections. The current renovation has been- The Fernley Swimming Pool has been closed for approximately six to seven months since late February 2026 for a major roof replacement and facility renovation. Now you sat October. Soooo 8 months for a new roof. The picture shows no other renovations. Comment publication date: 9/17/26, 7:14 PM Comment source: Electrical problem delays Fernley pool opening Comment author: P Comment text: Relative of the Mayor is to over see this site. Anyone who knows Fernley KNOWS this is more of the who you are related to and know business in this town. VOTE THEM ALL OUT AND THE CALIFORNIA TRANSPLANTS. Comment publication date: 9/16/26, 10:31 PM Comment source: Lift Station Failure Released Untreated Sewage Comment author: Christopher Walsh Comment text: Could you look into the strong recurring smell around Fernley? It smells like sewage and it can be bad enough that people don’t want to be outside or open their windows. It would be helpful to get an investigative journalist help the Fernley residents get a clear answer from the City, NDEP, and any involved facilities. I was really disappointed that the smell was not disclosed by my realtor when I moved here. I enjoy Fernley and am seeing the improvements that are being made. With Appreciation Comment publication date: 9/12/26, 2:49 PM Comment source: Sewage spill near City of Fernley Municipal Well 9